Miscellaneous News Thread

I understand that, but that wasn't my question. When you hear it, does it rhyme with "dull"?
I believe (for them) the answer is yes. Again, look at the link I posted. It explains how the "L" at the end is a soft L, and is easily masked by the overtones. More importantly, it has links to the pitch-adjusted samples, allowing anyone to hear both results. So instead of repeatedly asking what other people hear, or claiming that it's "clearly" one way or the other, or that it has to do with your speakers or playback device, just listen to the samples.
 
I believe (for them) the answer is yes. Again, look at the link I posted. It explains how the "L" at the end is a soft L, and is easily masked by the overtones. More importantly, it has links to the pitch-adjusted samples, allowing anyone to hear both results. So instead of repeatedly asking what other people hear, or claiming that it's "clearly" one way or the other, or that it has to do with your speakers or playback device, just listen to the samples.

I read the link you posted, but it doesn't help me understand. I don't hear anything like an "l" sound at the end, soft or hard. I'm at work and I'm not going to play any audio files here.
 
I read the link you posted, but it doesn't help me understand. I don't hear anything like an "l" sound at the end, soft or hard.
I know, I hear exactly the same thing as you. The importance of the L sound being soft, is that it's more easily masked by the overlayed sound, which sounds like an E. So we only hear the overlay sound, which masks the L sounds at both ends, to make them sound like "E"s to us.

According to various articles, some people don't hear the higher frequency overlay, and so it sounds like Laurel to them. It doesn't sound at all like an L sound to me, but when I listen to the sample in the link that's pitch-adjusted up 20%, it sounds exactly like Laurel. Supposedly, that's because now the overlay is too high in frequency to be heard over the main component, so all I hear is the main frequency.

Conversely, if someone hears Laurel at normal pitch, and then they listen to the pitch-adjusted down (20% or 30%) sample, they will now hear Yee-an-ee, because the overlayed frequency is low enough that they'll now hear it masking the main frequency.

Of course, this could all be bullshit. I listened to some videos on Youtube that pitch-shift the clip, but those don't work for me. I just keep hearing Yanni. So the clips in the link I posted are either great, or they're doctored (fake) to seem like the answer.

This much is true: two people can hear the same clip from the same device, and perceive the clip to be different.
 
Ok, tonight, the 3 of us (me, mrs, and scotch daughter) listened to the link from the Atlantic (the linguist), using the built-in speaker on my phone. At original pitch, the wife (as usual) definitely heard only laurel, I heard yanni, and the kid (who is known to have sensitivity to high frequencies) heard yanni. With the pitch lowered 20% or 30%, we all heard yanni. With the pitch raised 20%, I heard laurel, but the kid heard a mix of the two. At 30%, she also heard laurel. The wife also heard laurel.

So there you have it. The lower frequency band of the recording sounds like laurel, the overlaid distortion frequency makes it sound like yanni. Depending on your sensitivity in the audible range, you'll hear one or the other.
 
Thanks for the compliment on the wife, but your dickishness almost made me scrap posting the solution to all this. The following article by a linguist, contains pitch-shifted versions of the audio. I clearly hear the difference, I imagine all of you will too.
A Linguist Explains Why 'Laurel' Sounds Like 'Yanny'

I listened to the pitch shifted versions. All of them sound like "yarry" to me. There is no "ull" sound at the end no matter what speed it is played at. Always an "ee" sound.
 
I listened to the pitch shifted versions. All of them sound like "yarry" to me. There is no "ull" sound at the end no matter what speed it is played at. Always an "ee" sound.
Then you're either just being intentionally difficult for the sake of argument (high probability), or you have some seriously fukd-up hearing. According to the experts, the recording is of the word laurel, so it's there to be heard.

My daughter has a medical condition that likely contributes to her high frequency sensitivity, but even she hears laurel at 30% pitch shifted up. If you don't, that probably means that the overlaid frequency is still masking the recording for you. I imagine if that's the case, you'd be aware of having a strong sensitivity to high frequencies.
 
Then you're either just being intentionally difficult for the sake of argument (high probability), or you have some seriously fukd-up hearing. According to the experts, the recording is of the word laurel, so it's there to be heard.

My hearing might be bad. I'm not being intentionally difficult.

My daughter has a medical condition that likely contributes to her high frequency sensitivity, but even she hears laurel at 30% pitch shifted up. If you don't, that probably means that the overlaid frequency is still masking the recording for you. I imagine if that's the case, you'd be aware of having a strong sensitivity to high frequencies.

No, I've killed a lot of high frequency cillia attending rock concerts. If anything I'm less sensitive to high frequencies than the general population.

So you hear an "ull" sound at the end of the recording at some speeds? This is fascinating.
 
So you hear an "ull" sound at the end of the recording at some speeds?
Yes, exactly. At both 20% and 30% pitch shifted up, I hear lar-ull or lar-ell. My daughter hears sort of a hybrid at 20%, but hears laurel at 30%. What I hear in those samples is what I assume many people hear at the original pitch.
 
Yes, exactly. At both 20% and 30% pitch shifted up, I hear lar-ull or lar-ell. My daughter hears sort of a hybrid at 20%, but hears laurel at 30%. What I hear in those samples is what I assume many people hear at the original pitch.
I don't hear any of the timbres involved in an "ull" sound. It's all "ee", all the way to the end.
 
I don't hear any of the timbres involved in an "ull" sound. It's all "ee", all the way to the end.
Dude, you're repeating yourself. If your ear hears the overlaid frequency that's masking the main frequency, you'll only hear "ee", not "ull". It's not like they start morphing. It's either masked, or not.
 
Dude, you're repeating yourself. If your ear hears the overlaid frequency that's masking the main frequency, you'll only hear "ee", not "ull". It's not like they start morphing. It's either masked, or not.
OK. Does that bug you?

I'm not saying I'm right, just describing my subjective experience.

These aren't simple frequencies; they are timbres. There is no "main frequency" or "overlaid frequency", just a collection of frequencies changing over time.

But then ...

Someone applied a steep cutoff filter that makes it all clear:


Cut out frequencies below 2k and it sounds like "yeahwee". Cut out frequencies above 2k and it sounds like "laurel".

If you have good, young ears you should be able to hear the frequencies about 2k.

Now I'm saying I'm right.
 
This is the illustration in the article.
upload_2018-5-17_13-45-35.webp

I added the green arrow that's pointing to the additional frequency that's overlaid above the main components. The main frequencies are somewhat similar between the 2 graphs. They are not exactly the same, because the graphs represent the pure words, not the particular recording in question.

Anyway, if one hears the frequency that the green arrow is pointing to, you'll perceive the word as Yanni. Here's the graph of human hearing
upload_2018-5-17_14-10-12.webp

In the upper part of the vocal range (between 1kHz and 10kHz) you can see that the "equal loudness" lines are not linear at all. It dips to its most sensitive around 4kHz. So a person can have dips and peaks and slopes that vary from other people, and it could make the perception of certain frequencies much different, while one's overall hearing is perfectly fine.

Any other questions?
 
OK. Does that bug you?

I'm not saying I'm right, just describing my subjective experience.

These aren't simple frequencies; they are timbres. There is no "main frequency" or "overlaid frequency", just a collection of frequencies changing over time.

But then ...

Someone applied a steep cutoff filter that makes it all clear:


Cut out frequencies below 2k and it sounds like "yeahwee". Cut out frequencies above 2k and it sounds like "laurel".

If you have good, young ears you should be able to hear the frequencies about 2k.

Now I'm saying I'm right.

That's a good clip. And it does exactly the same thing as the pitch shifting, but in a cleaner, more absolute way.
 
With meme video post showing both. I can partially hear yanny but it still sounds like laurel to me.
 
That's a good clip. And it does exactly the same thing as the pitch shifting, but in a cleaner, more absolute way.

No it doesn't. Shifting the pitches doesn't remove them, not unless you shifted the 2k frequencies above 8k or so. That would be a 400% speed increase.

With meme video post showing both. I can partially hear yanny but it still sounds like laurel to me.

Then you aren't hearing the high frequencies. Here's a hearing test to find out which frequencies you can't hear:

 
Back
Top Bottom