DRC Madness #31 - I Can't Believe It Wasn't A Top 40

The votes are all in, but first there's a

SCANDAL!!

No, it's not Beatles-related.

It turns out one of the songs in the madness DID reach the top 40 in the US, but was accidentally listed in the "I Can't Believe It's Not A Top 40" thread as peaking at #46 (which is the song's UK peak). The person who made the mistake last August has the username 'sadchild'. I say we ban the bastard!

So "Mama I'm Coming Home", which actually peaked at #28 in the States, has been removed from the results.

And now...... ON TO THE RESULTS!
 
After thinking about how to present the results of Madness 31, I realized the only appropriate way to discuss the results of a madness called "I Can't Believe It Wasn't A Top 40" is course by doing a.....

Top 40 Countdown of songs that never made the Top 40!

But first, to add insult to injury, here are the songs that never made the top 40 ....... and then almost made our top 40 and didn't get there either!

Beatles "I Am The Walrus"
Coldplay "Yellow"
David Bowie "Changes"
Fatboy Slim "The Rockafeller Skank"
Tom Petty "Here Comes My Girl"
Van Halen "Hot For Teacher"
Wall Of Voodoo "Mexican Radio"


So although they walk away twice shunned, they can at least take consolation in the fact they did outperform 229 other candidates who also tried & failed to get onto our top 40.
 
The votes are all in, but first there's a

SCANDAL!!

No, it's not Beatles-related.

It turns out one of the songs in the madness DID reach the top 40 in the US, but was accidentally listed in the "I Can't Believe It's Not A Top 40" thread as peaking at #46 (which is the song's UK peak). The person who made the mistake last August has the username 'sadchild'. I say we ban the bastard!

So "Mama I'm Coming Home", which actually peaked at #28 in the States, has been removed from the results.

And now...... ON TO THE RESULTS!

Is this a scandal worthy of being called something-gate?
 
Hello everybody and welcome to the

DRC Never-Made-The-Top 40 Countdown


I'm S.C. Kasem and I'm all set to countdown the 40 biggest almost-hits in America!
​

N.O.T.40 is read coast to coast and around the world on great computer systems like Aaron's, Chuck's, Listener's and Hectic's. The whole world is able to read as we count down the 40 most almost-popular songs in the USA. These are the records (some of you but not enough of) you were buying and radio stations were (kinda) playing from coast to coast - from the rocky shores of Scotch, Maine to the sandy shores of Channel, California.

Position of songs that did not advance was determined by how many votes they got in their losing round. Ties were broken by number of votes in the previous round. If songs had the same amount of votes throughout every round they were in, a tiebreaker was held.

Wherever you are and wherever you go you can see S.C.'s Didn't-Make-The-Top 40 in the fifty states and around the world in countries where people would Rather Be Skiing. We won't stop 'til we reach the top. These are the not-quite-hits, the stars, and their stories. Now, on with the countdown!
 
#40 Buster Poindexter "Hot Hot Hot"

Why did New York Dolls frontman David Johansen take on the lounge act persona Buster Poindexter and cover a song by a calypso artist born in the West Indies that didn't make the UK top 40 back in 1983? He wanted to give it a Shot Shot Shot! Was he able to take it into the top 40? Not Not Not!

What does DRC think about this? It Ought Ought Oughta be a hit! What difference does that make in fixing this injustice? Nought Nought Nought! But we're still gonna go rum-bum-bum-bum, keep up this spirit and insist this party song, this fundamental jam, should have made the top 40 back in 1988. Olé olé!

 
#40 Buster Poindexter "Hot Hot Hot"

Why did New York Dolls frontman David Johansen take on the lounge act persona Buster Poindexter and cover a song by a calypso artist born in the West Indies that didn't make the UK top 40 back in 1983? He wanted to give it a Shot Shot Shot! Was he able to take it into the top 40? Not Not Not!

What does DRC think about this? It Ought Ought Oughta be a hit! What difference does that make in fixing this injustice? Nought Nought Nought! But we're still gonna go rum-bum-bum-bum, keep up this spirit and insist this party song, this fundamental jam, should have made the top 40 back in 1988. Olé olé!


Well, like I've said before, it played twice on the 90-minute mixtape at the Divi-Divi beachfront bar in Aruba in 1997. It was tied for #1 with Kokomo. So, just like George Thorogood's "Bad To the Bone", "Hot Hot Hot" has gotten a helluva lot more airplay than many #1 songs.
 
#39 REM "Pop Song '89"

"People have this idea of who I am probably because when I talk on camera, I’m working so hard to articulate my thoughts that I come across as very intense. But I’m in 'Shiny Happy People', 'Stand', 'Pop Song 89' [and] 'Get Up' too. Our fruitloop songs!" - Michael Stipe

Well, this little pop song came out in '89 (as clearly expressed in the song title) but it only peaked at #86. Here at the DRC, we thought it deserved to peak much higher but sadly it was left out of the fun, kind of like us as we watched the video back in the day and wished those black bars across everyone's chests weren't there! Fortunately the band posted the uncensored version to YouTube, so grab a bowl of Fruit Loops and watch the black-bar-less version of the video for a song that we strongly feel should have made the top 40 back in 1989. It peaked low but should have peaked high. High, high. High.

 
Well, like I've said before, it played twice on the 90-minute mixtape at the Divi-Divi beachfront bar in Aruba in 1997. It was tied for #1 with Kokomo. So, just like George Thorogood's "Bad To the Bone", "Hot Hot Hot" has gotten a helluva lot more airplay than many #1 songs.
And it was in 800 commercials and TV shows too.
 
#38 Beck "Where It's At"

Beck may have been trying to tell us where it's at, but we know where this song is not at... the top 40. It peaked at #61 in 1996. He's got two turntables, one microphone, and one top 40 hit.

But here at DRC, we know Beck's no Loser! Only a Jack-Ass would consider this guy a Lost Cause. Should "Where It's At" have been a top 40? Hell Yes! So grab a Beercan and celebrate DRC's #38 pick for songs that should have made the top 40!

 
Back
Top Bottom