DRC Madness #31 - I Can't Believe It Wasn't A Top 40

7330149cef1197f16433d7506a928cac837c2ee4.gif
 
The Beatles have had 52 top-40 hits. The Romantics had only two. All My Loving failing to make the top 40 is much more surprising than What I Like About You failing to make the top-40. In the event of a tie, All My Loving should be declared the winner.

 
The Beatles have had 52 top-40 hits. The Romantics had only two. All My Loving failing to make the top 40 is much more surprising
If you read what I posted earlier, it's not only not surprising at all, but technically, it wasn't even a single in the US for most of it's airing. If it had been released as a traditional single in the US, and it wasn't also up against 13 other Beatles' top 40's during the same year, it surely would've been top 10. I understand that people are free to vote based on personal preferences, but the situation should elicit absolutely no sympathy.
 
I read what you wrote, Mister scotch, but the weekly Hot 100 charts in the 1960s were, as per Billboard, "compiled from national retail sales and radio station airplay by the Music Popularity Dept. of Record Market Research." In theory, a song with heavy airplay could chart even before being released as a single. Pasadena top-40 station KRLA played All My Loving quite often for a few weeks but never listed the song on their Top 50 Tune-Dex surveys. The song was on KFWB's Fabulous Forty for the week ending March 28, 1964. It was listed, unnumbered, between songs #10 and #11 as "SPECIAL FROM LP."
 
I read up a lot on the Beatles when I was in college, so I’ve lived with the knowledge that All My Loving was not a charting hit, so it doesn’t surprise me. Whereas the Romantics song appeared to be all over the dial, so it surprised me years later to find it wasn’t a big chart hit.
 
I read up a lot on the Beatles when I was in college, so I’ve lived with the knowledge that All My Loving was not a charting hit, so it doesn’t surprise me. Whereas the Romantics song appeared to be all over the dial, so it surprised me years later to find it wasn’t a big chart hit.
Thank-you for your expert perspective.
 
I read up a lot on the Beatles when I was in college, so I’ve lived with the knowledge that All My Loving was not a charting hit, so it doesn’t surprise me. Whereas the Romantics song appeared to be all over the dial, so it surprised me years later to find it wasn’t a big chart hit.
For me, it's the massive scale of Beatlemania and how long the song has been popular, where the Romantics saturation was pretty short lived.
The film of girls losing their minds, swooning, and mobbing the Beatles was such a larger scale than anything that the Romantics got to enjoy makes All My Lovin the bigger surprise.
 
For me, it's the massive scale of Beatlemania and how long the song has been popular, where the Romantics saturation was pretty short lived.
The film of girls losing their minds, swooning, and mobbing the Beatles was such a larger scale than anything that the Romantics got to enjoy makes All My Lovin the bigger surprise.
That's quite a heartwarming sentiment, yet it ignores reality. The Beatles are becoming the Budweiser of DRC.
 
IMO if you (scotch) felt so strongly about "All My Loving", I woulda thought you'd bring this up when it was being considered for the Sweet 16 (aka before Round 1). It did end up in the Sweet 16.

Below is from a post after 15 of the Sweet 16 were determined, and 3 songs were fighting for that 16th spot.

Vote for which one is the 16th:
Beatles "All My Loving" 1.9
Indigo Girls "Closer To Fine" 1.9
Traveling Wilburys "End Of The Line" 1.9
The last round of the madness is a bit late to call foul.
 
...and let the record show I voted for Indigo Girls for sweet 16, not Beatles!

My first IG CD. Think I still have it too

My0yMjM4LmpwZWc.jpeg
 
Back
Top Bottom