DRC Madness #31 - I Can't Believe It Wasn't A Top 40

IMO if you (scotch) felt so strongly about "All My Loving", I woulda thought you'd bring this up when it was being considered for the Sweet 16 (aka before Round 1). It did end up in the Sweet 16.

Below is from a post after 15 of the Sweet 16 were determined, and 3 songs were fighting for that 16th spot.


The last round of the madness is a bit late to call foul.
Why didn't I bring this up when the song was 1 of 273 songs? Gee, I don't know. Maybe I didn't want to research 273 songs. Perhaps it made more sense to look into it when it came down to that song vs. another, and I said to myself "hmm, I wonder why that particular song didn't make the top 40, when 52 other Beatles songs did".

Having said that, I must declare that you've gone over-and-above on this Madness. It's been really well run, and it's not your fault that the song wasn't available as a single in the US for most of the time it was getting airplay. It has also been greatly entertaining to play each round. I just don't like it when every fear and admonishment harbored by IRBS turns out to be true.
 
Why didn't I bring this up when the song was 1 of 273 songs? Gee, I don't know. Maybe I didn't want to research 273 songs. Perhaps it made more sense to look into it when it came down to that song vs. another, and I said to myself "hmm, I wonder why that particular song didn't make the top 40, when 52 other Beatles songs did".

Having said that, I must declare that you've gone over-and-above on this Madness. It's been really well run, and it's not your fault that the song wasn't available as a single in the US for most of the time it was getting airplay. It has also been greatly entertaining to play each round. I just don't like it when every fear and admonishment harbored by IRBS turns out to be true.
It's lucky the Beatles were not considered 2 hit wonders. One madness saved.
 
Why didn't I bring this up when the song was 1 of 273 songs?
That I see. But it was singled out as one of three tied for vying for that last sweet 16 spot - making it so it advanced directly to the fifth round. There was a ton of discussion about it before first round. See page 2 into the top of page 3 of this thread. We were talking about this exact song in several posts, but nobody said "wait, disqualify this song".

I must declare that you've gone over-and-above on this Madness. It's been really well run,
Thanks I appreciate that. Next week, I'm looking forward to doing similar to what I did on the two hit wonders madness. I'll have a few presentation gimmicks that I think are gonna really make people laugh (or roll their eyes, or both)!
 
That I see. But it was singled out as one of three tied for vying for that last sweet 16 spot - making it so it advanced directly to the fifth round. There was a ton of discussion about it before first round. See page 2 into the top of page 3 of this thread. We were talking about this exact song in several posts, but nobody said "wait, disqualify this song".
Correct. Specifically, Channel98 presented his factoids (as he does) in support of the song. That would've been the perfect time for him to reveal details about the release and availability of the song, which I'm sure he had at his disposal (perhaps his disposal was being repaired). But he made no such disclaimer, and so the giant * that should've been placed next to the song was left out.

Of course, I'm no 40's 50's 60's music historian. So if the expert says nothing about it, who am I to be suspicious?
 
Thanks I appreciate that. Next week, I'm looking forward to doing similar to what I did on the two hit wonders madness. I'll have a few presentation gimmicks that I think are gonna really make people laugh (or roll their eyes, or both)!
Please delete any Beatles songs from the candidate list right from the get go. They will probably still win but don't want to give them a leg up and actually have them candidates.
 
DID YOU THINK THE VOTING WAS DONE?

Not yet!

Here are some ties to break before I can reveal the results next week. These songs had the EXACT same amount of votes EVERY SINGLE ROUND of the madness!

REM "It's The End Of The World As We Know It"
Who "My Generation"
ZZ Top "Sharp Dressed Man"

Oingo Boingo "Weird Science"
Indigo Girls "Closer To Fine"
 
REM "It's The End Of The World As We Know It"
Who "My Generation"
ZZ Top "Sharp Dressed Man"


Oingo Boingo "Weird Science"
Indigo Girls "Closer To Fine"
 
Is this some sort of a ploy to bump the Beatles off the throne? :unsure:

I'm voting either way.

REM "It's The End Of The World As We Know It"
Who "My Generation"

ZZ Top "Sharp Dressed Man"


Oingo Boingo "Weird Science"
Indigo Girls "Closer To Fine"
 
Back
Top Bottom