Hello Heartache, Goodbye Love got to #8 on the Fabulous Forty of KDWB in Minneapolis/St. Paul. The song did better there than in any other region. KFWB in Los Angeles played Hello Heartache, Goodbye Love – but it never appeared on their Fabulous Forty survey. KRLA in Pasadena played the song – but it never appeared on their Top 50 Tune-dex. It didn't make the Top 25 of WMCA in New York. It was on the top 40 of WLS in Chicago for only two weeks, peaking at #31.
Peggy March sang the song – lip-synched to it, actually – on American Bandstand, October 19, 1963. In 2025, Peggy (real name: Margaret Annemarie Battavio) continues to perform at fairs and concerts and on cruise ships. Here is her first television appearance, on The Perry Como Show, April 24, 1963. And yes, she lip-synchs to the recording – but Perry's orchestra replaced the fade-out with an ending.