Miscellaneous News Thread


you see the people who figured this out?

Screen-Shot-2016-02-11-at-12.58.32-PM.png


pretty much anyones first thought of what a bunch of nasa nerds look like. except maybe the woman in black, she looks kinda normal.
 
OK, I'll bite. What's wrong with it, and why the conspiracy?
I'm no physicist. There are accusations that he fudged the constants to make observations of the transit of Mercury fit his theory. If gravity propagates at near the speed of light, it's hard to figure out how objects stay in orbit around each other.
 
I'm no physicist.
But you play one on TV?
There are accusations that he fudged the constants to make observations of the transit of Mercury fit his theory.
Newton's theory didn't explain the anomalies of Mercury, and apparently Einstein's theory does, but knowing how difficult it is to scientifically verify this stuff, it doesn't surprise me that an observed phenomenon did not jive 100%, and so some liberties might have been taken. But that wouldn't necessarily mean the theory is wrong, just that the observation isn't a complete proof.
If gravity propagates at near the speed of light, it's hard to figure out how objects stay in orbit around each other.
You've lost me here. The propagation of the force of gravity (at speed of light) has nothing to do with the effect of gravity (attraction of masses). If I'm standing 10 feet from someone who turns on a flashlight, I will see the light all day long at my 10 ft distance, even though the light beam is traveling out into space at C.
 
But you play one on TV?
Newton's theory didn't explain the anomalies of Mercury, and apparently Einstein's theory does, but knowing how difficult it is to scientifically verify this stuff, it doesn't surprise me that an observed phenomenon did not jive 100%, and so some liberties might have been taken. But that wouldn't necessarily mean the theory is wrong, just that the observation isn't a complete proof.
You've lost me here. The propagation of the force of gravity (at speed of light) has nothing to do with the effect of gravity (attraction of masses). If I'm standing 10 feet from someone who turns on a flashlight, I will see the light all day long at my 10 ft distance, even though the light beam is traveling out into space at C.
It would be more satisfying without fudge factors.

Speed of gravity matters when you think about two objects in motion. A orbits B, but B is moving. Does A orbit the spot where B is, or where it was when gravity left on its way to A?
 
Also, Newton's theory had holes in it. It was those holes that led to Relativity. I want the holes in Relativity to lead to something new, not just be spackled over.
 
Back
Top Bottom