Miscellaneous News Thread

It's the forcing that's criminal. Encouraging not so much.
Forcing = murder.
Encouraging relentlessly = involuntary manslaughter.
Both criminal, according to our judicial system (not me). If you're not satisfied with that, maybe you can file a motion.
 
For the love of god please agree to disagree!


Sent from my SM-N910V using Tapatalk
Why? Is this discussion making you uncomfortable?
Forcing = murder.
Encouraging relentlessly = involuntary manslaughter.
Both criminal, according to our judicial system (not me). If you're not satisfied with that, maybe you can file a motion.

According to this court. I have no doubt this will be overturned on appeal.

Encouraging can be incitement, not manslaughter.

Encouraging can only be incitement if suicide is ciriminalized.
 
This is a disturbing case and there is very disturbing video in the link:

Trial start for Vanderbilt football player accused in rape | Daily Mail Online

It's a bit confusing because the 2 main players in this article are both named Brandon. So, the arguement goes that Brandon 1, this guy:
41906DD300000578-4619772-image-m-12_1497914860206.jpg


was pressuring/encouraging/goading (but not forcing) Brandon 2, this guy:
418F63B400000578-4619772-image-a-1_1497914036915.jpg


into raping a woman with a water bottle. Brandon 1 is already in prison as a convicted rapist.

Now I find this interesting because it plays into the seemingly endless discussion we are having about the suicide girl. My stance is very similar to the suicide case. Much like I believe you can't be talked into killing yourself, I also believe you can't be talked into raping someone. I don't care how many people, or how close they are to me, or how long they tried to convince me, I am sure that no one could goad me into me into either killing myself or raping someone. And I think this same rationale applies to most everyone. Brandon 2 decided to rape this girl himself. It was his doing and he should face the full force of the consequences for his actions. Same with the guy who killed himself. It was 100% his own doing and it is simply wrong to try to find others responsible for his actions.
 
Last edited:
My wife and I discussed the suicide verdict last night. She holds a similar view to mine.

One problem with this verdict (and others like it) relates to the slippery slope of assigning blame and causation. There could be hundreds of people in this man's life who contributed to his suicidal mental state. Singling her out as the only culpable party doesn't seem to have a logical basis. And if we accept the complexity of human thought and emotion, plus this idea that the people whose actions led him to suicide have some share of legal guilt, how do ever know when to stop? There could be hundreds of people involved directly with him, then thousands who contributed to their mental state and behavior, in a network extending back though history. Then there's the thorny issue of genetics and environmental influences. How much of his mental state was purely a result of simple brain chemistry imbalances? If this woman hadn't been there, would he have sought someone similar?

As a fatalist I can see that none of us are ultimately responsible for anything. We are physical objects obeying the laws of physics. If I commit a crime it is because I had to. Free will is an illusion. It can all be blamed on people, genes, chemicals, whatever that led me to this point in time and space, to this configuration of neurons and neurotransmitters.

I also understand that I evolved a sense of free will so I would feel personal responsibility. Humans without that wouldn't last long as a species. Even if I know it is an illusion, it is a useful illusion. If I do something bad I accept the blame, no matter what my girlfriend told me, no matter how crappy my childhood was. (A serious brain chemistry problem is a different matter, but I hope you get the idea.) We hold ourselves and each other responsible for our actions because that benefits everyone, including ourselves.
 
This is a disturbing case and there is very disturbing video in the link:

Trial start for Vanderbilt football player accused in rape | Daily Mail Online

It's a bit confusing because the 2 main players in this article are both named Brandon. So, the arguement goes that Brandon 1, this guy:
41906DD300000578-4619772-image-m-12_1497914860206.jpg


was pressuring/encouraging/goading (but not forcing) Brandon 2, this guy:
418F63B400000578-4619772-image-a-1_1497914036915.jpg


into raping a woman with a water bottle. Brandon 1 is already in prison as a convicted rapist.

Now I find this interesting because it plays into the seemingly endless discussion we are having about the suicide girl. My stance is very similar to the suicide case. Much like I believe you can't be talked into killing yourself, I also believe you can't be talked into raping someone. I don't care how many people, or how close they are to me, or how long they tried to convince me, I am sure that no one could goad me into me into either killing myself or raping someone. And I think this same rationale applies to most everyone. Brandon 2 decided to rape this girl himself. It was his doing and he should face the full force of the consequences for his actions. Same with the guy who killed himself. It was 100% his own doing and it is simply wrong to try to find others responsible for his actions.

For me these are not the same in that rapists are just jerks. They are mentally stable although rapists. Therefore, it is impossible for #2 to have been talked into rape by #1. Is #1 on trial in this case?
 
Yes, let's. But I am looking for education. I change my mind often and am open to any new information or perspective you can share.
If you are sincere about learning about the subject, you should talk to a professional.
None of us can pull you from the vortex.

It's not a binary subject.
 
If you are sincere about learning about the subject, you should talk to a professional.
None of us can pull you from the vortex.

It's not a binary subject.
I don't understand any of that. What sort of professional do you want me to talk to? What "vortex" are you talking about?
 
Back
Top Bottom