DRC Madness #31 - I Can't Believe It Wasn't A Top 40

#11 Clash "Should I Stay Or Should I Go"

One of the Clash's most popular songs, "Should I Stay Or Should I Go", peaked at #17 in the UK on release in 1982. Then after being used in a jeans ad in 1991, it recharted and soared all the way to #1. It was also a top 40 hit in Austria, Canada and Ireland.

In the US, it peaked at #45. This is the second time DRC has taken issue with Billboard over the Clash lately. Last summer, we named them the #3 biggest not-subjectively-a-frickin-two-hit-wonder (behind Nirvana and Pink Floyd). And now we're seeing one of many reasons this band shouldn't have even been in the running. It's obviously not the greatness of their songs, it's the not-greatness of the Hot 100 methodology!

 
#10 John Fogerty "Centerfield"

Put me in coach! "Centerfield" was originally relegated to the b-side commercially as the flipside to the #20 hit "Rock And Roll Girls". Eventually it was given its own promotional release for radio stations (as a double a-side) and a music video as seen on MTV. Years later, George W. Bush told Americans while campaigning that it was his favorite song. Thanks to "Centerfield", Fogerty became the first musician to be honored by the Baseball Hall of Fame. And for Record Store Day 2018, "Centerfield" scored the a-side of the baseball picture disc while "Rock And Roll Girls" sat on the b(ench)-side.

But beat the drum and hold the phone! Back in 1985 "Centerfield" was swinging for the fences and reached #20 in Canada. But somehow it whiffed here in the States, peaking at #44. That's a swing and a miss for the Hot 100. Our faith in that chart is going... going... gone!

 
Yeah. It was a fresh release.
It has great staying power though.
Maybe since it never really went away, it just seems like it should have been higher.
Still shocks me though.
 
#9 Modern English "I Melt With You"

Here's a little love song written about dying while fucking! Aww, that's cute. Robbie Grey explained, "I don't think many people realized it was about a couple making love as the bomb dropped. As they made love, they become one and melt together." Doesn't sound like hit material, but the song not only got heavy rotation on MTV, it was later used in commercials for Ritz crackers, M&M's, Burger King and Taco Bell - and sung by the cast of Glee. It's one the top 500 songs most-played songs on US radio and the band was given a lifetime achievement award at the BMI Awards in 2017 in honor of 3 million spins.

But the song only reached #78 in the US back in 1983. It seems the Hot 100 was not geared to give proper credit to a slow-burning hit? Grey recalled, "Someone picked up an import from England and started playing it on mainstream radio in America." Then, according to the Miami New Times, "The song spread virally from station to station." But not fast enough for the Hot 100 to realize it was set to become a bona-fide classic, evidently.

 
#9 Modern English "I Melt With You"

Here's a little love song written about dying while fucking! Aww, that's cute. Robbie Grey explained, "I don't think many people realized it was about a couple making love as the bomb dropped. As they made love, they become one and melt together." Doesn't sound like hit material, but the song not only got heavy rotation on MTV, it was later used in commercials for Ritz crackers, M&M's, Burger King and Taco Bell - and sung by the cast of Glee. It's one the top 500 songs most-played songs on US radio and the band was given a lifetime achievement award at the BMI Awards in 2017 in honor of 3 million spins.

But the song only reached #78 in the US back in 1983. It seems the Hot 100 was not geared to give proper credit to a slow-burning hit? Grey recalled, "Someone picked up an import from England and started playing it on mainstream radio in America." Then, according to the Miami New Times, "The song spread virally from station to station." But not fast enough for the Hot 100 to realize it was set to become a bona-fide classic, evidently.


First of all, I had no idea what the song was about. I just thought it was a love song. But anyway, yeah, given the popularity and airplay, this is maybe the biggest shock to me. I mean, c'mon; not even in the top 40? I would've expected it to get close to #1. This is proof of the division between new wave/alternative rock and pop. And it's clear evidence that from that time on, pop was irrelevant (and still is, only more so).
 
Shocker......
The chart placement.....not necessarily what the couple was doing when they melted into a puddle of post-apocalyptic love goo.
 
Last edited:
#8 Police "Message In A Bottle"

Sting worked out the guitar riff for "Message In A Bottle" to a captive audience - his dog. "I used to play it over and over again to my dog in our basement flat in Bayswater and he would stare at me with that look of hopeless resignation dogs can have when they're waiting for their walk in the park." It became The Police's first #1 in the UK & Ireland, and was a top 5 hit in Australia, Belgium, Canada and The Netherlands. And since today is the day after the Super Bowl, here's a little trivia tidbit: Sting performed this with No Doubt at the 2003 Super Bowl halftime show.

According to Billboard, "Message in a Bottle" has an "irresistible" hook. But someone should have sent out an SOS back in late 1979! In the US, "Bottle" peaked at #74. Are you telling us that higher charting songs by Pleasure, Dann Rogers, Joyce Cobb, The Flying Lizards, Mistress and Tom Johnston were really bigger hits than this classic? I doubt it!

 
#7 Peter Gabriel "Solsbury Hill"

As Peter Gabriel sat meditating on Little Solsbury Hill in Somerset, England, he was considering more than just quitting his band. He told Rolling Stone, "When I left Genesis, I just wanted to be out of the music business. I felt like I was just in the machinery." In a letter to the press at the time, he mused, "My future within music, if it exists..."

Gabriel took some time off with family but soon began writing demos which he passed along to producer Bob Ezrin (Alice Cooper, Kiss) - who was instantly enamoured with "Here Comes The Flood". One of the songs they recorded was written about Gabriel's decision to depart Genesis, and it became his first top 20 hit in Germany, Belgium, The Netherlands and the UK.

But in the US, "Solsbury Hill" peaked at an unimpressive #68. Eventually the Hot 100 would recognize Gabriel's genius as five singles from 1982-1992 made the top 40. But with Rolling Stone later naming it the #472 Best Song of All Time, we here at DRC's hearts are going BOOM BOOM BOOM just thinking about the injustice of the song never breaking the top 40 on release!

 
#6 Rush "Tom Sawyer"

Canadian lyricist Pye Dubois of Max Webster presented Rush drummer Neil Peart with a poem he'd written about a modern day rebel named Louis. Peart added on to it, changed the protagonist to "Tom Sawyer", and it became what Geddy Lee once told Rolling Stone is their "biggest song". In 2009, VH1 named it the 19th greatest hard rock song of all time. It's one of five songs for which the band was inducted into the Canadian Songwriters Hall of Fame in 2010.

Rush has had no problem reaching the top 40 in their homeland, getting there seven times. And they've reached the top 40 four times in the UK. But the Hot 100 refuses to register the greatness of the band, allowing them in only once (one hit wonder?? phooey!!) with "New World Man" in 1982. Between 1977 and 1986 they had seven more songs climb up the Hot 100 only to be stopped somewhere between #44 and #88. "Tom" was the biggest of the band's shoulda-been-bigger's, getting stopped at #44.

 
#6 Rush "Tom Sawyer"

Canadian lyricist Pye Dubois of Max Webster presented Rush drummer Neil Peart with a poem he'd written about a modern day rebel named Louis. Peart added on to it, changed the protagonist to "Tom Sawyer", and it became what Geddy Lee once told Rolling Stone is their "biggest song". In 2009, VH1 named it the 19th greatest hard rock song of all time. It's one of five songs for which the band was inducted into the Canadian Songwriters Hall of Fame in 2010.

Rush has had no problem reaching the top 40 in their homeland, getting there seven times. And they've reached the top 40 four times in the UK. But the Hot 100 refuses to register the greatness of the band, allowing them in only once (one hit wonder?? phooey!!) with "New World Man" in 1982. Between 1977 and 1986 they had seven more songs climb up the Hot 100 only to be stopped somewhere between #44 and #88. "Tom" was the biggest of the band's shoulda-been-bigger's, getting stopped at #44.


I think "Tom Sawyer" is a better rocker than "Limelight", but I think the latter is more top 40 radio friendly. So while both should definitely be top 40, I'm a little less shocked with this one.
 
I was 10 when Moving Pictures came out so I didn't get exposed to it right away. When I was 11 or 12, that was my first introduction to Rush. A friend of mine told me Pictures was a great album so we listened to a few songs on it. I didn't get into it. He kept insisting that "Tom Sawyer" was an awesome song. It didn't click with me. But "Tom" was the song he kept telling me I should like.

I then got into Rush casually in 1984 with "Distant Early Warning" on MTV. Then I became more of a fan with "The Big Money" in 1985. In 1988 I listened to the whole Hold Your Fire album over and over (and it's still my favorite of theirs). Next was the live A Show Of Hands which got me into some of their earlier songs like "Closer To The Heart". After those two albums, I went back and recognized how good "Tom Sawyer" actually is.
 
Back
Top Bottom