DRC Madness #31 - I Can't Believe It Wasn't A Top 40

#33 Indigo Girls "Closer To Fine"

Emily Sailers and Amy Ray met in the sixth grade and began singing together as high school students. After an indie single and album, they were signed by Epic who released their self-titled 1989 album featuring Kasim Sulton (Utopia/Blackheart/Todd Rundgren), Michael Stipe (REM) and Hothouse Flowers. The latter sings backups on the duo's highest charting hit and signature song "Closer To Fine" which reached #52 in 1989.

Well, I went to the doctors, the mountains, the children, the fountains - heck I even interviewed some middle-aged Subaru-driving lesbians - but I was only pointed in a crooked line in my quest to figure out why this song couldn't break into the top 40. I suppose the less we seek the Hot 100 for something definitive in terms of determining if a song is a hit, the closer we are to being the DRC.

 
#32 U2 "New Year's Day"

I remember staying up late on New Years Eve at my aunt's house. And when I wake the next morning, all is quiet on New Year's Day. Until I turn on MTV, of course. Man, they must have played this video hourly - at least - all day long.

There's no way that amount of play could've have been a contributing factor for the song's position on the Hot 100 though. Despite a #2 peak in Ireland and a top 10 showing in the UK, it stalled at #53 in the US. Here at DRC we think this song, which Rolling Stone named as the #435 greatest song of all time back in 2004, should have easily broken the top 40.

 
#32 U2 "New Year's Day"

I remember staying up late on New Years Eve at my aunt's house. And when I wake the next morning, all is quiet on New Year's Day. Until I turn on MTV, of course. Man, they must have played this video hourly - at least - all day long.

There's no way that amount of play could've have been a contributing factor for the song's position on the Hot 100 though. Despite a #2 peak in Ireland and a top 10 showing in the UK, it stalled at #53 in the US. Here at DRC we think this song, which Rolling Stone named as the #435 greatest song of all time back in 2004, should have easily broken the top 40.


On New Year's Eve, 1985, I had recently gotten out of college and started my career up here, and I was living in an apartment in Burlington, MA. At midnight, I put this on - I guess somewhat loudly - for the group of partiers at my place. At about 12:07 AM, the police showed up, and told me to shut it down.
 
On New Year's Eve, 1985, I had recently gotten out of college and started my career up here, and I was living in an apartment in Burlington, MA. At midnight, I put this on - I guess somewhat loudly - for the group of partiers at my place. At about 12:07 AM, the police showed up, and told me to shut it down.
Did you call them fascist shite wankers!?!?!
 
#31 David Bowie "Rebel Rebel"

glam rock /glam räk/ [noun] a style of rock music first popular in the early 1970s, characterized by male performers wearing exaggeratedly flamboyant and feminine clothes, makeup and hairstyles - sometimes giving the appearance of androgyny.

In 1973, after David Bowie released an album of cover songs, he was trying to figure out his next career move. A Ziggy Stardust musical? Adapting George Orwell's 1984 into music? A William S Burroughs-inspired urban apocalypse album? Dabble in funk and soul? His next album Diamond Dogs could be said to have a bit of it all. "Rebel Rebel" was one of two songs salvaged from his abandoned Ziggy Stardust musical and served as the album's lead single. It was a top ten hit in at least eight countries across the pond and Cash Box called it "Bowie's best single ever".

But Billboard, you've got us in a whirl! "Rebel Rebel" only reached #64 here in the US. We at DRC feel it should have been a bona fide top 40 hit. Because we love bands when they're playing hard. We want more and we want it fast! "Rebel Rebel" - we love you so.

 
I really can't come up with any explanation for why this wasn't a Billboard hit. It's got the riff, it's got the hook, it's got lyrics you can sing along with. It's got a good beat and you can dance to it. And it's Bowie.

So I did some research, and here's what I found.
1) It was released in 1974, not 1973.
2) "Rebel Rebel" was released as a single with a different mix in the US and Mexico in May 1974. Bowie was not satisfied with creating an enduring "dance-floor anthem", so he recorded a new mix in New York in April 1974, a "Latin dub mix". The US mix is shorter (2:58) and more up-tempo, dense and camp than the UK single, featuring "sine waves" of percussion, an original backing vocal line that is preceded by a "rush of backward echo", acoustic guitar and a new arrangement that buries the signature riff beneath phasing. The US mix begins at the first "hot tramp" lyric at the 1:20 mark in the original UK mix. Within a couple of months, it was withdrawn and replaced by the UK single version.

I think this explains it.
 
That would explain it for sure. They took a great song and screwed with it until they broke it.

PS I didn't say it was released in '73.
 
#30 Elton John "Tiny Dancer"

When Bernie Taupin first came to America with Elton, he met a lot of women on Sunset Strip who were "free spirits, sexy in hip-huggers and lacy blouses, and very ethereal, the way they moved. So different from what I'd been used to in England. And they all wanted to sew patches on your jeans. They'd mother you and sleep with you - it was the perfect Oedipal complex." His soon-to-be first wife, Maxine Feibelmann, who traveled with them as the 'seamstress for the band' (sewing costumes and fixing clothes) was the other inspiration for what became the song "Tiny Dancer". It reached the top 20 in Canada and Australia.

But thinking about how close this song came to the top 40 here in the States, peaking at #41, makes us here at DRC a little sad. I need a hug. Hold me closer, Tony Danza.

 
#29 Rush "Limelight"

What do you call Italian food being eaten by a Canadian rock star in the sauna? Spa-Geddy! Mr. (Spa) Geddy Lee told 'In the Studio with Redbeard' that the song is about Neil Peart's "difficulty with coming to grips with fame and autograph seekers and a sudden lack of privacy and sudden demands on his time." In Canada, the song was a top 20 hit and in 2010 was inducted into the Canadian Songwriters Hall of Fame. Rolling Stone ranked it #435 on their list of the Top 500 Greatest Songs of All Time.

But you know what DID avoid the Limelight? This song. In America. It only peaked at #55 back in 1981. I'd say Billboard was ill-equipped to act, and had insufficient tact, if this song couldn't make the top 40!

 
Normally, you wouldn't expect a serious rock album to produce top 40 hits. But it seems like they put Limelight on the album specifically for that reason. I guess it didn't fit in between the Human League and Men Without Hats.
 
Normally, you wouldn't expect a serious rock album to produce top 40 hits. But it seems like they put Limelight on the album specifically for that reason. I guess it didn't fit in between the Human League and Men Without Hats.
"Limelight" was put on the album at the last minute to balance the length of side A & B on the album and more specifically the cassette. It is the ultimate irony that the song they did the least amount of work on and threw it in for just balancing act wound up as their ONLY top 40 hit.

I thought for sure "Tom Sawyer" would win the madness. There really is not greater injustice as what Billboard has done to Rush. And before you say rock songs can't make the top 40, there are lots of them on the chart. Maybe not #1 but in the top 40. And Rush had no issues anyplace else in the world getting into the top 40.
 
#28 Billy Idol "Rebel Yell"

The 'rebel yell' was a battle cry used by Confederate soldiers during the American Civil War. Confederate soldiers used the yell when charging to intimidate the enemy and boost their own morale. Up until 2020, 'Rebel Yell' was brand of Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey likely deriving its name from the battle cry. Keith Richards was reportedly an avid drinker of Rebel Yell and one night Richards, Idol, Mick Jagger and Ron Wood were taking swigs of it when Idol said he thought it would make a good song title.

That song he wrote was a top 10 hit in Canada, Australia, New Zealand and the UK! And in 2009, VH1 named it as the 79th best rock song of all time. But back in 1984, despite being in regular rotation on MTV, it only peaked at #46 in the US. We here at DRC think it should have climbed the Hot 100 a lot more, more, more!

 
Yeah, I don't know what else to say. It was a big hit song, it was all over the radio, and all over MTV. It has a catchy chorus and it's a great dance tune.
 
Back
Top Bottom