Donny Osmond recorded a lot of remakes. Or am I thinking of Johnny Rivers? No, I guess they both did. Osmond had hits with remakes of Young Love, Too Young, The Twelfth Of Never, A Million To One, Hey Girl, Go Away Little Girl, Puppy Love, I Knew You When, Lonely Boy, C'mon Marianne, When I Fall In Love and Are You Lonesome Tonight. Osmond's remake of Frankie Avalon's 1959 number-one hit Why peaked at #13 on the Billboard Hot 100 in October 1972. The song was written by Bob Marcucci and Peter DeAngelis, co-owners of Chancellor Records. In the 1980 film The Idolmaker, Ray Sharkey starred as a frustrated performer who discovers two teen idols. It was based on the life of Marcucci, who discovered and managed Frankie Avalon and Fabian. Marcucci served as the film's technical adviser.
Why has also been recorded by Anthony Newley, Barry Young, Horton Wells, Rikki Henderson, The Young Generation and the Swedish dance band Bosse Påhlssons. Here is Frankie Avalon's original, his seventh and final top-ten hit: