Kurt Warner - Hall of Famer?

Discussion in 'NFL' started by AJ_II, Jan 19, 2009.

?

Is Kurt Warner a Hall of Famer?

  1. Yes, but only if he wins Super Bowl XLIII

    6 vote(s)
    20.7%
  2. Yes, even if he loses Super Bowl XLIII

    14 vote(s)
    48.3%
  3. No either way

    9 vote(s)
    31.0%
  1. AJ_II

    AJ_II New Member

    What do you think? Here's a look at his resume...

    -four-time Pro Bowl selection
    -two-time AP MVP (1999, 2001)
    -three Super Bowl appearances (1999, 2001, 2008)
    -Super Bowl XXXIV Champion and MVP
    -only the second QB to lead two different teams to the Super Bowl (Craig Morton)
    -'02 to'07 was mainly used as a second-string QB or was injured
    Last edited: Jan 19, 2009
  2. semipenguin

    semipenguin Bum Looker

    Yes, he should...:)

    Can anyone breakdown his stats as an indoor Quarteback vs an outdoor QB?...:scratch:

    Thanks...:)
    Posted via Mobile Device
    Last edited: Jan 19, 2009
  3. Aaron

    Aaron Moderator

    I say yes. I'd be curious to see his stats vs. Steve Young's stats. Both spent some time on the bench, but, both were extremely productive at times too.
  4. IdRatherBeSkiing

    IdRatherBeSkiing This space for rent

    I'd say no. He has sucked for several years as well (anyone remember his Giant years?).
  5. goreds2

    goreds2 Well, you know........

    I'd say if he wins the Super Bowl plus has a couple more good seasons, he is in.
  6. Wolf

    Wolf The Lone Wolf

    He is definatily Hall of Fame bound!
  7. TOM C.

    TOM C. Member

    Superbowl MVP= automatic hall. imho
  8. AJ_II

    AJ_II New Member

    So you'd vote in Larry Brown? Deion Branch? Dexter Jackson?
  9. TX WJ

    TX WJ Intelligent Donkey

    If you are a QB that wins the Mvp and a Superbowl you are in.
  10. goreds2

    goreds2 Well, you know........

    I think TOM C. meant if Kurt wins the SB MVP this year for his second one, he is in.

    (Correct, Tom C?)
  11. semipenguin

    semipenguin Bum Looker

  12. AJ_II

    AJ_II New Member

    I'd vote him in. I think if he wins the game in two weeks, it'll be a near lock for the HoF.

    Heard something interesting today. Kurt Warner will be a free agent after this season, and apparently the Rams are showing some interest in bringing him back to St. Louis.
  13. TSSJimmyCoN

    TSSJimmyCoN New Member

    he's pretty much a lock at some point even if he doesn't win...pretty up and down career but the ups have it
  14. TSSJimmyCoN

    TSSJimmyCoN New Member

    a better question is if ROETHLISBURGER would be a hall of famer? I think yes
  15. goreds2

    goreds2 Well, you know........

    He still has a few years left in him. He will probably make it.
  16. TX WJ

    TX WJ Intelligent Donkey


    A little early don't cha think?

    Here is a question I saw.

    You are starting a new team

    You get to pick one of these guys to be your QB

    Matt Ryan
    Beth Rothlisberger
    Phillip Rivers
    Eli Manning
    Jay Culter

    Who would you pick and why?
  17. blyons200

    blyons200 These pretzels are making me thirsty.

    He's Hall of Fame matierial in my opinion. The rags to riches story just adds to the legend.
  18. TSSJimmyCoN

    TSSJimmyCoN New Member

    Roethlisburger. 2/3 afc championship games won. the only 1 he LOST was because he was a rookie throwin into the starting position in week 6 of the 2004 season. This will be his 2nd superbowl in only 5 years in the league and I am willing to bet they stomp all over the cards. He is a proven winner and already has the 7th all time passer rating for qbs with a minimum of 1500 attempts.
  19. Supafly

    Supafly New Member

    I'd take Beth Rothlisberger.

    During practice she'd wear a red vest, white Victoria's secret shear lace wireless bra, and some pink Lycra boy shorts way too tight in the front. :bigclap:
  20. TSSJimmyCoN

    TSSJimmyCoN New Member

    as sung by peter criss

    "beth I hear you callin! but I can't come home right now. Me and the boys are playin. and we just can't find the souuuuuuuund!!! just a few more hours, and the superbowl is ours....Beth I hear you callin but Beth what can I do???"

Share This Page